⌂ Tenant GuideTENANT / VICTORIA

Disclaimer

This independent website provides general information and educational resources about renting in Victoria. It is not legal advice, does not consider your individual circumstances and does not create a lawyer–client relationship. The website is not affiliated with VCAT, any government agency or the organisations linked here.

Laws, procedures, forms and contact details may change. We do not guarantee that the content is complete, accurate or current, or that any application or argument will succeed. Check the current legislation, official guidance and orders in your case before acting. Case summaries and examples do not guarantee similar outcomes.

Seek advice from a qualified lawyer or tenancy advice service about your circumstances. If you face an urgent deadline, hearing or eviction, obtain help promptly; do not delay action while relying on this website. External links are provided for reference and their content is outside our control.

← All case studies

CASE STUDY / VICTORIA

VCAT · Arrears, absence and review

Valenton v Shehata

(Residential Tenancies) [2023] VCAT 11

Follow the relationship between procedural opportunities and substantive evidence through review, repayment and stay decisions.

GENERAL LEGAL INFORMATION · CHECKED 9 NOV 2026

OutcomeFinal review dismissed; PO affirmed; stay revoked
RESEARCH SCOPE

Based on Tenants Victoria’s 2026 digest §3.8; full reasons were inaccessible. The digest does not provide complete reasons for each early permission or adjournment. The 5 January 2023 decision date is not labelled an oral hearing.

01 / TIMELINE

Timeline

Verified procedural milestones. Dates of applications, hearings and published decisions are distinguished; an event is not necessarily a hearing.

  1. 2022-02-14 → 2022-03-09

    Arrears NTV; later PO applicationBackground / application
  2. 2022-06-29

    First absent hearing ↗Hearing / order node
  3. 2022-07-01 → 2022-07-22

    Review filed; reopening granted ↗Hearing / order node
  4. 2022-08-10

    Repayment plan ordered ↗Hearing / order node
  5. After 31 August; exact date unreported

    First return adjourned again ↗Hearing / order node
  6. 2022-09-26

    Second absent hearing and PO ↗Hearing / order node
  7. 2022-09-27 → 2022-10-03

    Further review permission sought and granted ↗Hearing / order node
  8. 2022-10-20

    Absence at review hearing ↗Hearing / order node
  9. 2022-10-28

    Further permission and stay ↗Hearing / order node
  10. 2022-11-03

    Adjournment for legal instructions ↗Hearing / order node
  11. 2022-11-10

    Hearing arranged for medical needs ↗Hearing / order node
  12. 2022-11-15

    Review hearing and financial material ↗Hearing / order node
  13. 2023-01-05

    Final decision delivered ↗Hearing / order node

02 / WHAT WAS DECIDED, AND WHY

Hearings & orders

Unknown details are marked. Background descriptions and statutory frameworks are not presented as verified reasons for an unavailable order.

2023-01-05

Final decision delivered

Result / procedural step
Review dismissed; second PO affirmed; stay revoked.
Legal basis / recorded reason
Section 120 reasonable-case test and s 331 proposal: inadequate compliance, documentation and capacity. Section 330A is also listed in the digest.

Source:Tenants Victoria 2026 case digest §3.8, printed pp.14–15 ↗

03 / PRACTICAL LESSONS

Lessons for renters

The suggestions below are this guide’s application of the material, not additional court findings or personalised legal advice.

01

Prepare absence and merits

Use separate chronologies and evidence references for the excuse and the defence.

02

Demonstrate performance

Show current-rent and arrears payments, budget and income; explain what changed after any earlier failure.

03

Read every order

Check scope, expiry and conditions; permission to apply is not a final tenancy outcome.

04

Do not plan around repeated reviews

Seek help promptly, obey evidence directions and arrange suitable participation.

Limits on using this case

This does not establish unlimited reviews or automatic stays. Early procedural relief did not prevent the final possession outcome; missing reasons require original orders or full reasons.

04 / SOURCES & READING

Sources & limits

Check full reasons, original orders, subsequent history and current law before relying on an individual proposition. VCAT decisions generally do not bind other members.

TENANT / COMMUNITY

Talk to people here

Connecting…

Community room

Public room · Visible to everyone who joins

Say hello to start a conversation.

Enter to send · Shift+Enter for a new line